Replacing very dated screen porch hardware

Hello there!

Thank you for reaching out to us. 

You could keep your outside pushbutton handle and replace the spring and the inside handle with the 40-038 and 40-117. If you do want to replace the complete handle set, the closest we carry would be the 40-034 and the 40-034K with the key. Note that the 40-034 has an inside handle that is a little different than yours so you might also want to order the 40-117 which matches up better to your existing inside handle. 

If you don't care about the outside key lock then you could go with the 40-215 pull-up lock. It has the same 1-3/4" hole centers and the inside handle is close to the one you now have. As for the inswing door, take a look at the 40-028. This is close to the one you now have. Take note that the key cylinder for this handle is no longer available so you will need to reuse the key cylinder you now have. Review the specifications for these parts and see what you think. 

As for your outswing door, I would go with the 40-128 Deluxe closer. That looks like the closer you already have on the door. For the inswing closer I would go with the standard 40-077 being that it is at the header. Also if you want to change the closer bracket, we carry the 40-006 inswing bracket. 

When you say you "can't get the old lock out of the door", are you referring to the key cylinder? If so, try using a spray lubricant like WD-40. The cylinder might just be wedged in the hole in the door. As for the 40-038 spindle, that was to be used on your existing Push button in your first two photos.

Your keeper seems a little too tall for the 40-117. With that said, take a look at the 40-085 keeper. This keeper looks like it could be a little lower in profile than the one you have. You could also pack out the 40-117 using some cardboard pieces to build up the height of the 40-117 to meet the keeper. Another idea is to try filing down your existing keeper.