Broken storm door handle

Thanks for reaching out to us, Andrew. I believe you have an older Cole Sewell storm door that is no longer available. If I am looking correctly, its seems the lever handle is not connected to the upper dead bolt. It looks like two separate parts. I'd like to suggest possibly replacing your bottom lever handle with the "pull up" type handle such as the, 40-152 while keeping your existing dead bolt lock. There is also the option of replacing the complete handle and dead bolt handle with the 40-058. A good word of advice, you may need to drill more holes to install the new top dead bolt.  See which part would make the better fit for you.