Is there a better option to this Andersen screen door?

It is possible to purchase a replacement screen door for your Andersen patio sliding screen door. The after market sliding screen doors available at the big box stores are not very good and will not work better than your existing door. There are smaller companies that manufacturer after market sliding screen doors that will look a little different than your existing Andersen screen door but may work better. You will need to find these companies locally because I do not believe anyone ships screen doors.

You may be able to repair your existing Andersen screen door. If your screen door is jumping off the track it could be either that your screen door is too loose or there is a bump on the sliding door track. If your door is too loose you need to adjust your rollers to tighten the door to the track. If there is a bump on the track you need to try to smooth the track back out. If your sliding screen door is hard to open it could be that your rollers are worn and broken and need to be replaced.

I will post your question and maybe 'home owner from Rhode Island' or another user will have a suggestion for a local place in or near Rhode Island.