I have the same clip you show in your picture and I ordered the new black replacements to try them. They did not work for me. The attach onto the screen just fine, but when I tried to catch it onto the window frame, it did not line up. Mine have one catch for the window frame, the black ones have two, so I tried squeezing them together and pushing them into the frame, but it is not holding right. :( I have been looking for the replacement clip for years and just cannot find one.