Patio screen Door Keeper

Our screen door keeper has broken off and we need a replacement. Your Patio Screen Handle Assembly (Product Code: 83-003) looks like ours with the same hole and size distances. I don't mind getting a new handle assembly, Which door keeper should we order? Our damaged one looks like either (Product Code: 85-011) or the narrow version(Product Code 85-014). Perhaps there is a different one that goes with your screen handle assembly? Thanks.