Screen door handle replacement

You have an old Cole Sewell handle, but they're no longer in business so you won't be able to find an exact match for this. I recommend something like our 40-058, 40-152, or even 40-131. I have personally used our 40-152 pull up lock in the past as a replacement for the Cole Sewell handle. The escutcheon plate is a little shorter at 8" were yours is at 9", which is just an aesthetic issue. Take a look and see what you think.