These are all starting to break from sun rot or old age lol

Thanks for posting! Your window tilt latch looks very similar in style to either the 26-126 Top Tilt Latch or the 26-169 Acorn Tilt Window Lock; both of which are non-handed. To determine if either of these would be a fit, carefully look over the dimensions for each of them and compare them to your existing latch.

These are both only available in black.

Alternate image for 26-126

Alternate image for 26-169

Alternate view of 26-169