Weather stripping needed
John Rose
Thanks for posting. I am afraid the Therma-Flu brand isn't associated definitively with certain weatherseals. This is seldom the case with any brand. The 58-173 does come up a lot for this make however, so take a look below and see what you think.
I'm a bit confused. Is the foam seal you show in your photos the original, or the one the handyperson used erroneously? If it's the original, the 58-180 is our closest match. This has an adhesive base, so you'd have to find a way to adapt it to your door, but take a look and see if is close. Either way, your handyperson did not do you many favors by discarding the original! Let me know if you have further questions.