Wheels

Apparently, there is no exact replacement.
Is there a substitute?



Hi there!
I'm afraid we don't carry that white piece. However, we've recommended our 23-041 to customers with your older Stanley roller in the past. Take a look and compare our dimensions to your existing part to confirm that this will make a good replacement for your closet door.

Do I need two matching new rollers? Or can i use one of the old rollers?



The white piece is an old stabilizing clip. Stanley used to make the 23-041 roller with that white clip, but over the years they decided that it wasn't a necessary piece for the roller to function and phased it out. If you think you need it for your door to work, your best bet would be to check a local Mom and Pop shop.
You can reuse your old rollers, but if one broke from wear and tear then the other rollers probably aren't far behind.