Thank you for the pictures, Terry. These look pretty much the same just by eyeballing them. How do they differ, exactly? What is the distance between the screw hole centers for your original handle and what is it for the new handle?
They do not line up. Look at the two outer holes, the one at the top and the one at the bottom. The holes in the first handle are spaced longer than in the second handle.
Well, they are supposed to measure 3-1/2" on centers. What size is your original? I need to know exactly how they differ so that we can find the best possible replacement for you.