screen door handle 4 inches by 2 1/4

Hello! Your old screen door handle set appears to be a match for our 83-040 . This isn't specifically designed to be used on Norco doors, but it's a generic part that has been known to work for tons of different brands. Look it over and see what you think!

Dimensions for 83-040

Thanks for the follow-up, I actually missed that detail in your first post. I've never personally seen a larger version of this screen door handle set, but give us a little more time to look into it and we'll see what we can dig up. I'll get a few more eyes looking at this, too. 

I think that the 83-040 that Tom recommended is a newer version of your old screen door handle. I couldn't find this older version anymore, though. I'm not sure why the manufacturer changed its design so much but this does appear to be our best option.

Would it be possible to retrofit the 83-040 to work on your door? If you could drill new holes for it you can use a pop rivet to fill the exposed holes from the original setup. I would only recommend trying this if you're handy, though, since it may require some improvisation. 

Unfortunately, we did not. I don't believe the original handle is available anymore. While I can't guarantee that it will work, the 83-040 could be the best option available.  I'm very sorry that we can't be of more help.