
Window Balance 27 4 EX CMC

If your sash is precisely 22.5 pounds, then the 2740 stamp should have worked fine. This is calibrated to hold 19 through 26 pounds.
Can you verify that the old balance was identical to the replacement in every last respect? Even a small difference may be hugely impactful. Seeing the originals would allow us to give better analysis.
Otherwise, based on the data you've provided, there's no reason why the 2740 would be acting this way.
Thank you for your patience in this matter. Looking at your photos, I see no reason why your balances have failed. For a 22.5 pound sash, our hardware should have functioned without issue.
Since the only issue seems to be that the balance is too strong, you could go with the weaker 2730 stamp and see if that works better. However this is only designed to hold 13 through 19 pounds. It's technically not supposed to work on your sash, since it's too weak, but I can think of no other possibility.