Searching for Caldwell 25 4 EP Balance

Hello Melissa and thank you for contacting us. Please take a look at both our S380-26 and S385-26 channel balances. These are the closest matches we have. These look the same, however, the difference between these two parts lie within the measurement of the bottom balance shoe. The depth of the Series 380 measures 1" and for the Series 385, it measures 1-3/32". You will need to measure the depth of your bottom shoe, like in the diagram below, to determine which balance would work best as a replacement. Whichever one decided can go with a 2540 option. 

Alternate view of 15-004